No 713 Let The Right One In by John Ajvide Lindqvist

right oneI don’t usually read something if I’ve seen the screen adaptation, I prefer to read the book first, to create my own world and people it with my imagination. Reading Let The Right One In really reminded me why. I saw Let The Right One In a few years ago and really loved it, so it was incredibly hard to read the novel and not compare the two. I do think it is interesting though that John Ajvide Lindqvist wrote the screenplay for the movie, because the things I didn’t like about the book are also the things that didn’t seem to make their way into the movie.

Set in the early ‘80s, it features a 12 year old boy named Oskar whose alcoholic father and overprotective mother are divorced. Oskar is an outcast and is badly bullied by other kids in his class. He meets Eli, a twelve year old girl who just happens to also be a 220 year old vampire and a sort of adolescent romance is played out against a backdrop of death, madness and paedophilia.

 

As a vampire story, it’s a great one. It is gruesome and horrific and not at all romantic about the vampire life. The murders are frequent and disturbing and there are some fantastic set pieces involving cats, acid and underpasses. But what strikes you when reading it is the pain and isolation of the vampire for whom all choices have been distilled into the need for blood to survive.

As Eli says to Oskar;

If you could wish someone dead and they died. Wouldn’t you do it then? Sure you would. And that would be simply for your own enjoyment. Your revenge. I do it because I have to. There is no other way

Eli’s isolation as a vampire corresponds directly to Oskar’s as a victim of bullying and what the novel does beautifully is use the vampire myth as a metaphor for that human isolation. Eli and Oskar are children who have been let down badly by the adult world. Oskar’s father is a drunk, his mother distracted and his teachers uninterested. Eli’s ‘father’ of sorts is her procurer of blood, in thrall to Eli and her pre-pubescent body due to his paedophilic tendencies. This is a town full of lost boys, with missing, dead or ineffective father figures. The town the novel is set in was manufactured for communities, but

Something went wrong. They thought all this out, planned it to be…..perfect, you know. And in some damn wrinkle it went wrong, instead. Some shit.

The community has folded in on itself, left itself open to the outside evil. The novel becomes an existential character study about “outcasts” living on the fringe of society. Drunkards, disaffected glue-sniffing teens, everyone trying to escape their reality while true horror creeps closer and closer. This for me is where the book didn’t work so much. It is sprawling. Each chapter introduces a new character, a new viewpoint which in some way detracts from the central story of Oskar and Eli. A narrower focus would have made for a more engrossing read.

The relationship between Oskar and Eli is poetically told. He reminds her of what it is like to be a child while she becomes his rock, his way of becoming someone new and teaches him to stand up for himself with devastating consequences. The scenes of bullying are as difficult to read as the scenes of barbarity and the friendship that materialises between the children is based on an understanding and loyalty so horribly missing from the rest of the story. They find each other when they are both achingly alone, and it is the ordinary fact of their loneliness rather than their extraordinary circumstances that makes the book more than the sum of its gory set pieces and genre status.

What is ultimately haunting about Let The Right One In is not the subject matter of vampires, blood and fear, but the way in which ordinary people can treat each other when they lose hope and the pain that can come from trying to make your way through the world when you are in any way different. All Oskar wants is to be loved for himself, to not always be the victim;

For a few seconds Oskar saw himself through Eli’s eyes. And what he saw was……himself. Only much better, more handsome, stronger than what he thought of himself. Seen with love. For a few seconds.

Let The Right One In spells out its message with a bit too much force for me. The film was more subtle and left more to the imagination, but this tale of Oskar and Eli is hard to shake off and the ostensibly happy ending raises more questions that it resolves. Has the right one been let in? How does Oskar, or for that matter, anyone, ever know?

estella

I read this as part of the Estella Project  and will be reading Geek Love for this challenge later in the summer.

 

 

 

So, do you like to read the book before you see the movie? Are there any adaptations you can think of that improve on the book?

Next up for anyone who wants to read along, The Woman Upstairs by Claire Messud

woman upstars

Read On: iBooks
Number Read: 34
Number Remaining: 712

Advertisements

32 thoughts on “No 713 Let The Right One In by John Ajvide Lindqvist

  1. Great review! I loved the film, now I won’t feel guilty about giving the book a miss (though like you, I usually read the book first). I haven’t seen the stage adaptation, but friends have told me it’s wonderful.

    Like

    • Neither have I Geoff, the Swedish version was damn near perfect so I’ll leave it at that. It’s interesting to read the book and see what was left out and changed for the movie.

      Like

  2. I usually tend to like the book more and try to read it beforehand. I’ve only liked Keira Knightley’s Pride and Prejudice more than Austen’s work.

    Like

  3. I almost always read the book before seeing the movie and I usually prefer the book. Sometimes I’m surprised to discover that I prefer the movie, however. I think The Help was a better movie than book, for example.

    Like

  4. It’s not really my kind of book – and yet I might watch the film. Not sure why! I usually prefer to read the book first and usually prefer the book. However years ago I read and loved Captain Corelli’s Mandolin but the ending really annoyed me – when the film came out, even though it was critically slammed, I loved it mainly because they changed the ending to exactly how I thought it should be!

    Like

  5. Good review. I have this on my classics list to read so quite looking forward to it, although like you, I have already seen the film. In actual fact I used to prefer to read the book first but sometimes I find I’m less critical of the film if I see it first and then read the book to get into the real depth of the character’s feelings, etc.
    Lynn 😀

    Like

  6. I have the book and am planning to read it before I watch the film, to make sure the film doesn’t first fix the characters in my mind.

    Another review I read suggested that a sense the girl is grooming him, given she may look like a child but is actually a predator over two centuries old and as such not even remotely his peer. That interpretation makes it all the more horrific, as Oskar then is simply a child left open to exploitation by a seemingly affectionate predator. Did it strike you that way at all?

    Like

    • It did Max, but it’s an unwilling grooming. The logistics of survival. There is also the hint that Oskar will end up like Eli’s ‘father’ before him, as he grows older and Eli remains forever a child.

      Like

  7. Film adaptions better than the book; The Godfather, The Shining, Misery, Double Indemnity to name but a few. Films that do justice to the excellent books they are adapted from; Howard’s End, The Hours, A Room With A View, To Kill a Mockingbird again to name but a few.
    I never go out of my way to read a book of a film adaption. If I see a film based on a book I have read it is pure co-incidence. I read E.M. Forster’s novels long before they became movies.

    Like

  8. Personally I don’t think Blade Runner is the movie version of Do Androids Dream of Electric Sleep? It’s inspired by it, sure, but they have very little in common beyond some elements of the base concept.

    Like

    • No criticism of Blade Runner there by the way, I think it’s a great movie, including the theatrical release. People tend to forget that if we hadn’t been blown away by that there never would have been a theatrical cut to get excited about.

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s