No 681 The Hand That First Held Mine by Maggie O’Farrell

hand held mine
Secrets and the fallacy of being able to keep them hidden seem to be a hallmark of Maggie O’Farrell’s fiction.

This is the third of her novels that I have read and in each, her characters are trying to deal with the hidden secrets and concealed truths of their pasts that ripple through generations. In After You’d Gone, a traffic accident leads a young woman to question her past relationships and in The Vanishing Act of Esme Lennox, the reappearance of a long forgotten aunt unravels a web of lies and shame.

The Hand That First Held Mine has a similar premise, exploring the effect of an unspoken truth on several lies, but it is also a poetic musing on motherhood, memory and what it is that we think of as making up ourselves. This is a tale of gaps and losses, reconstructions and remembering.

The book is made up of two concurrent story lines. In the 1950s, reckless Lexie Sinclair has escaped her home in the countryside to make a life for herself in bohemian Soho after falling in love with the handsome and exciting magazine editor Innes Kent, whose home life is far from straightforward. In present day London, Elina, and artist and Ted, a film editor, are recovering from the traumatic birth of their first son. Elina almost died during the birth and cannot remember much about what happened, while Ted finds that fatherhood has brought back some deeply hidden childhood memories that don’t tally with what he knows about his upbringing.
Elina and Ted are filling in the gaps in their lives, just as is the reader. Maggie O’Farrell’s narrator acts as a kind of editor, slowing down action, fast forwarding and forewarning us of the action. It is a risky narrative style, but it works. The reader is always aware of the bigger picture, the wider narrative arc and of the links between the two storylines, between the past and the present, become more apparent the more we read.

She crosses and recrosses the paving slab where Innes first embraced Lexie in 1957; she passes the kerbstone where Lexie stood, trying and trying to hail a cab to take her to the hospital; she leans for a moment against the piece of wall against which Lexie and innes posed for John Deakin on an overcast Wednesday in 1959. And right where the girl from upstairs is grinding out her cigarette is where, in wet weather, it is possible to see the ghost outline of letters spelling ‘elsewhere’ and probably no one notices this and if they did they wouldn’t know why

As Elina tries to remember the birth of her son and Ted tries to reconstruct his early family life, we are trying to see the connections between these four characters and acting as a kind of director, O’Farrell guides us to the truth in a masterful and perfectly paced manner. All of the characters feel removed from their lives at times of trauma. Innes’ magazine is tellingly called Elsewhere and Ted and Elina’s sense of self and sense of each other as a couple are thrown adrift by the birth of their child.

Maggie O'Farrell and her daughter, Photograph by Graham Turner for the Guardian
Maggie O’Farrell and her daughter, Photograph by Graham Turner for the Guardian

O’Farrell writes incredibly well about motherhood – the joys and the frustrations, the difficulty of simply leaving the house with a new born and the pain of sleeplessness. Both Lexie and Elina find their ‘selves’ subsumed by motherhood,

The shock of motherhood, for Lexie, is not the sleeplessness, the troughs of exhaustion, the shrinkage of life, how your existence becomes limited to the streets around where you live, but the onslaught of domestic tasks; the washing and the folding and the drying. Performing these tasks makes her almost weep with furious boredom…

The domestic work of having a child is knowingly portrayed – the nappies, the wipes, the planning, the nervousness, but O’Farrell also explore the joy of being a parent, an often unimaginable joy.

She could mention that she had been unprepared for this fierce spring in her, this feeling that isn’t covered by the word love, which is far too small for it, that sometimes she thinks she might faint with the urgency of her feeling for him, that sometimes she misses him desperately even when he is right there, that it’s like a form of madness, of possession, that often she has to creep in to the room when he has fallen asleep just to look at him, to check, to whisper to him. But instead she says, ‘Fine. Good, thanks’.

It is also interesting to see the point of view of the father in the early days of childhood – in a subversion of literary convention, Ted’s place in the post-natal upheaval is examined and placed under the spotlight, to the extent that he begins to question his own upbringing.
As well paced and well plotted as the book is, it is the poetry of it that is most striking. O’Farrell is a perceptive writer, focusing on detail and intimacy to ground the story and emphasis the experience. Her descriptions of Soho in the 1950s are evocative and enthralling, like the John Deakin photographs that inspired the book.

Girl in Café, late 1950s John Deakin, The John Deakin Archive
Girl in Café, late 1950s
John Deakin, The John Deakin Archive

So, Innes and Lexie ricocheted like metal balls in a pin-machine….to jazz clubs, to eating houses, to Innes’s flat, to gallery openings, to Jimmy’s on Frith Street, to poetry nights in a smoke-hung basement where thin girls with black polo-necks and parted hair circled like moths around the poets with beards and pints.

It is a seductive scene and the early section of the book suffers a little by comparison when the action shifts from Lexie and Innes to Ted and Elina. Once the stories begin to converge however and that magnetic pull is in force, the mastery of the storytelling is evident and Maggie O’Farrell has you hooked again.

My Book Strings has also reviewed The Hand That Once Held Mine for Reading Ireland Month and you can read her review here.
Read On: iBooks
Number Read: 66
Number Remaining: 680

Ireland Month Irish Literature The 746

Cathy746books View All →

I am a 40 something book buying addict trying to reduce the backlog one book at a time!

17 Comments Leave a comment

  1. Excellent review Cathy – a big Maggie O’Farrell fan I read this when it first came out and you’ve captured the essence of it so well; her masterful storytelling had me sitting into the early hours until I’d finished it then frustrated there was nobody around to discuss it!

    I remember reading a quote from Maggie that while she didn’t like writing poetry, studying it taught her to be economical – make sure every word earns its place – and she certainly does that to create beautifully lyrical & effective prose.


  2. I really enjoyed your review, Cathy. I have a copy of this novel in my own TBR (not quite in the six hundreds, but sizeable nonetheless!). I like your comments on the common themes in some of O’Farrell’s novels, the focus on hidden secrets and concealed truths of past lives that ripple through the generations. I hadn’t considered it before, but you’re right. Looking forward to reading this one at some point.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. I completely agree with your review. Her descriptions of motherhood really struck a cord with me. I liked that it wasn’t all just happiness and perfection, but also doubt and endless laundry. I’ll definitely read more of O’Farrell’s novels!

    Liked by 1 person

  4. After reading the review of this at My Book Strings, I had already decided that I will definitely be reading it! I’m curious now, though, to know which of the 3 of her books you liked the best?

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Tasmanian Bibliophile @Large

'Inside a book is a different world...'


A friendly space for all horror, mystery & speculative fiction lovers

Plucked from the Stacks

book reviews and chatter

The Intrepid Arkansawyer

The Intrepid Angeleno is presently in Arkansas.

Books and Me!

All things Bookish and more!

Lizzie Ross

Reading, writing, dreaming

Book of Secrets

Mystery, Thriller, and Gothic Book Reviews


A plume with a hue

Books Are The New Black

Book Reviews and Book Talk

%d bloggers like this: