Miss Emily by Nuala O’Connor – review & giveaway!
While we are trying for others, power of life comes back, very faint at first, life the new bird, but by and by it has wings.
Emily Dickinson, Letters of Emily Dickinson
I was lucky enough to attend the launch of Nuala O’Connor’s new book Miss Emily at the Gutter Book Shop in Dublin last month.

Miss Emily is her third novel, following on from You and The Closet of Savage Mementoes and depicts the fictional relationship between the poet Emily Dickinson and her Irish maid Ada Concannon in 1860s. During this time, Dickinson famously rarely left her house in Amherst, dressed all in white and wrote most of the poetry that would be published after her death. Told in dual voices, the relationship between the reclusive poet and her bright, talkative maid is teased out as they bond over baking and domestic chores with an attention to small detail that feels appropriate for a book set almost entirely in one house.

In alternating chapters we explore the forging of a female friendship across class and background. Despite her family’s disdain for their closeness, Emily sees something of herself in Ada. Both are strong and independent in their choices, yet both are bound by the expectations of society and their place within it. Emily is at liberty to write all day while Ada is in service, but likewise, Ada is free to go to the circus when it comes to town, while Emily could not do something so inappropriate, as much as she would like. Yet both these women have also made life choices on their own terms. Feeling constrained in Ireland, Ada emigrates on her own, barely out of her teens. Emily, feeling constrained by polite society and the expectation upon her to marry and have a family, retreats from that society to write her beloved poems.
I do not wish for travel or brave new lands, only a house surrounded by a sprawling orchard that holds orioles and bluebirds that trill for my ears alone; a cosy home with a kitchen uncluttered by others. I do not desire a man or babes; a husband would demand too much, I fear, of my time, or my very self.
While the chapters alternate between Ada and Emily, experiences and thoughts overlap giving a depth and understanding to both their characters. By showing us Emily through Ada’s eyes and through her own thoughts, O’Connor questions the myth of Emily as the mad woman in the attic, shutting out the world to nothing but words.

The woman behind the words comes to the fore, a woman who loved literature and baking, loved her family, had a sweet tooth and was a devout friend. The depth of her empathy emerges as Ada faces a trauma that threatens her new life in America and what becomes clear is that both these women transcend the norms expected of them in an honest and true manner.
But convention never has been, and never will be, my first choice. I have chosen not to live as woman is supposed to live. The choice is mine…
There is an attention to detail of the customs and language of the time and the book contains some beautiful, lyrical prose. Dried pears are ‘silenced yellow tongues’ while a good man has ‘kindness…as rich as yolk in him’ while the descriptions of cooking and baking are rich and vivid. Like Emily, we see the poetry in the everyday. The passages about the process of writing are also intriguing as O’Connor deftly captures Emily’s overwhelming need to write and to write often.
Words lie in me like water in a riddle’s well. They tempt me, like nothing else. Not man, not God….Yes, words tempt and tease me and they send me teetering forward.
Both Ada and Emily are vividly conveyed, their voices alive and true. This tale may be fictional, but it still adds something to the history of Emily and her ‘vital, immortal words’. Her famous choice to not leave her home and to wear white are given context and understanding and appear more logical than unusual as Emily pares down her life to what she deems essential. O’Connor beautifully captures this decision by Emily in a passage echoing her poetic use of the dash;
From now on I shall be candle-white. Dove-, bread-, swan-, shroud-, ice-, extraordinarily-white. I shall be blanched, bleached and bloodless to look at; my very whiteness will be my mark. But inside, of course, I will roar and soar and flash with colour.
O’Connor success here is to show the reader the flashes of colour beneath the white, to capture the spirit of Emily Dickinson, without relying heavily on her poems or letters, rather by using their essence and spirit. Although it is undoubtedly an historical novel, it reads more as an ode to an unlikely friendship between two very different women, women who know their own mind and understand where home is for them and what strength they need to attain it.

I will be in conversation with Nuala O’Connor about this wonderful novel at the Crescent Arts Centre, Belfast on 25th November 2015 which I am very much looking forward to and you can book tickets here.
I am also giving away a signed copy of Miss Emily to readers of my blog. To be in with a chance to win, simply comment below or share this post on Twitter. Competition is open world-wide and will close on Saturday 19th September at 6pm when I will draw a winner with Random Picker. Good luck!
Naomi at Consumed by Ink has reviewed Miss Emily here, as has EJ at ebookclassics here. Check out their views!
Irish Literature ada concannon amherst crescent arts centre belfast emily dickinson historical fiction irish literature miss emily nuala o'connor the closet of savage mementoes
Cathy746books View All →
I am a 40 something book buying addict trying to reduce the backlog one book at a time!
There is no frigate like a book
To take us lands away,
Nor any coursers like a page
Of prancing poetry.
This traverse may the poorest take
Without oppress of toll;
How frugal is the chariot
That bears a human soul!
LikeLike
Nice. I should use that at the start of the review! I’ll take that as an entry then?
LikeLiked by 1 person
Well, you might think that; I couldn’t possibly comment.
LikeLike
I love this review, Cathy. I love that you point out all the ways the two women are similar, despite their age and class differences. And, it’s true that the book made Emily’s eccentricities seem almost natural.
Have fun on November 25th!
And, thanks for linking to my review. 🙂
LikeLike
Almost forgot – very nice photo of the two of you!
LikeLike
Thank you! I was a bit excited!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Niall, I have the first 4 lines of that poem on a coaster on my writing desk 😊Love it!
Thanks a million for the review, Cathy! Glad you enjoyed the novel.
LikeLike
My pleasure Nuala, the book was just wonderful!
LikeLike
A perceptive review, nicely done. I love the passage that was quoted: “From now on I shall be candle-white …” I just got “Emily” from the library, but a copy signed by Nuala is something I would treasure. Cheers, R.
LikeLike
Thanks so much! Consider yourself entered!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Great review and lovely photo! I have something of a fascination for Dickinson so would love to be entered!
LikeLike
Thanks!
LikeLiked by 1 person
I am making my way through a collection of Emily poems. I enjoy the sidenotes left by the previous owner. Do count me in.
LikeLike
I’m reading her poems too. Consider yourself entered!
LikeLiked by 2 people
Very nice review indeed. This book is next on my to-buy list but I would love to win a copy first! Thanks.
Shauna.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thank you Shauna! Good luck.
LikeLike
What a brilliant and deeply intriguing review, Cathy! It sounds like such a fascinating book. I studied some Dickinson in my university and her poetry always struck me as hauntingly beautiful. I’d love to be entered to your giveaway! 🙂
LikeLike
Thank you Akylina, it’s a beautiful book. I think you would enjoy it.
LikeLiked by 1 person
This books looks so interesting and inspiring. I’d love to read it!!
LikeLike
Enjoyed reviews and the passages you’ve quoted sound good. Nuala O’Connor is an author that I meant to get around to but I’ve never quite made it. I read a lot of good things about Closet of Savage Mementoes and had it on my ‘to buy’ list – alas it never got further than that! It sounds like a book I’d enjoy so I’d love to be entered – and I will also try harder to get ‘Closet’ further than a list on my iPhone!
LikeLike
Plus, you’ve been lucky here before Col! I haven’t read Closet either, but You is great.
LikeLike
Loved The CLoset of Savage Mementoes and looking forward to reading Miss Emily. How great to have the opportunity to meet and listen to the author, that always adds a wonderful layer to the subsequent reading. Great review!
LikeLike
Thanks Claire, I really want to read Closet now!
LikeLiked by 1 person
An insightful review, Cathy, that has me panting to read the book. Please enter me into the draw.
LikeLike
Consider it done!
LikeLike
Great review, I want to read Miss Emily even more now! You and the Closet of savage Mementos are fantastic. I love Dickinson’s poetry so the book appeals on so many fronts!
LikeLike
It’s a really lovely book Sarah!
LikeLike
Super review Cathy – I’ve had my eye on this book and its on my “to buy/borrow from library” list but I’d love to win a copy. I really enjoy literary figures being portrayed in fiction. And I wish I was in Belfast so I could come and listen to you and Nuala!
LikeLike
Thanks! You’re entered!
LikeLike
I visited her house in Amherst this summer, I’d love to read this book. Count me in!
LikeLike
After reading this book, I would love to go there!
LikeLike
I love Emily Dickinson’s poetry, which is why I was initially very hesitant to read this book. I haven’t been all that lucky with fiction that involves real people lately. But Naomi’s and your review have me convinced to give the book a try. Have fun on November 25; it sounds like it will be a wonderful experience.
LikeLike
Fingers crossed for the draw TJ!
LikeLike
Great post! This book sounds really interesting. I’ve always liked Emily Dickinson’s poems, even though some of them make me a little sad. A great reminder to go back to some of the old stuff!
LikeLike
The book is really lovely amd beautifully written. Good luck!
LikeLiked by 1 person
This sounds wonderful – I have the Closet of Savage Memories – on your recommendation – on the TBR ready to read and Miss Emily sounds equally fantastic – I’d love to be entered…
LikeLike
I’d love to hear what you think of Closet as I haven’t read it. Good luck!
LikeLike
I’ve heard only good things about Miss Emily.
ps. Great blog Cathy.
pps. I have twins too!
LikeLike
Hi Claire, how brilliant! What age are yours?
LikeLike
Nine, girls, fraternal. Chalk and cheese but a great team. They just separated into two bedrooms this month. Tried once or twice before but they crept back together. Little sister is 5. And you?
LikeLike
Boy and girl aged 4, also chalk and cheese. Just started school. Not sure how long they can stay in the same room but they won’t hear of being separated at the minute 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’d love to read this book – Emily Dickinson is one of my favorite poets!
LikeLike
Consider yourself entered!
LikeLike
Interesting idea to alternate the voices. Like the sound of it but dare not buy given the hundreds of books already unread
LikeLike
Like I’d said a few months ago, I enjoyed your review. I ended up reviewing Emily myself soon after. http://literaryorphans.org/ttl/ray-nessly-reviews-miss-emily/
LikeLiked by 1 person
Brilliant! Glad you enjoyed it.
LikeLike