No 500 Swann by Carol Shields

Carol Shields is one of those authors who never disappoints. The Republic of Love was in my Top Five books of 2016 and I have enjoyed all the work of hers that I have read. Swann is a playful and insightful look at the work of literature and academia as a group of disparate characters jostle for position as authority on the work and life of a newly discovered poet, Mary Swann, the ‘Emily Dickinson of Canada’.


Swann is the story of four individuals who become involved in the life of Mary Swann, a rural Canadian poet whose unique and naïve poetry is discovered literally hours before she is violently murdered by her husband.

The mysterious life of Mary Swann is told in chapters from the point of view of each of the four protagonists. Sarah Moloney is the feminist scholar credited with having discovered Mary’s work, while Morton Jimroy is a biographer of Ezra Pound who has taken Swann as his latest subject. Rose Hindmarch was the librarian in Mary’s town and now runs the Mary Swann Memorial Rooms while Frederic Cruzzi was Mary’s first and only publisher, who may have had a greater influence on the work than anyone could guess.

Swann is a novel about biography – what we keep and what we leave out when exploring the life of someone else. Morton Jimroy needs an explanation of Swann’s murder in order to find the hook to hang her writing on, but her writing comes from the ordinary, the everyday. Sarah Maloney dismisses Mary’s notebook as unimportant because it contains meal plans, lists of chores, notes on the weather. However, these are the very things that influenced Swann’s work, the ordinary that makes her words universal.

All the characters here are hiding the pieces of Mary’s life that they don’t like until any true picture of the woman, the writer, is lost. Sarah hides Mary’s notebook, while Rose denies the reality of the books that Mary borrowed from the library in order to protect her reputation. Frederic Cruzzi has never admitted that his wife inadvertently almost destroyed Mary’s original manuscript and that some of the words in her work may not be her own. Concurrently, someone appears to be stealing important artefacts relating to Swann’s work, from all of the protagonists.

Through all these omissions, Shields explores how reputations are shaped, not by the work itself, but by the industry that springs up around that work and comes to define it.

Universities are nothing but humming myth factories. Dear God. How we love to systemize and classify what is rich and random in life. How our fingers itch to separate the tangled threads of theme and anti-theme, moral vision and moral blindness, God and godlessness, joy and despair, as though all creativity sat like a head of cabbage on a wooden chopping block, ready to be hacked apart, first the leaves, then the hot, white heart. Scholarship was bunk—if they only, only knew. It was just a matter of time before the theoreticians got to Mary Swann and tore her limb from limb in a grotesque parody of her bodily death.

Shields takes this idea a step further, showing how each of these narrators has inserted themselves into Mary’s story until the notion of Mary as an autonomous writer has all but disappeared, and she is merely Swann – a jumble of ideas and theories far removed from her work, and indeed, her life. Shields is interested in the gulf that exists between art and its audience and in the shaping of reputations that may or may not be justified.

By now—it was morning—a curious conspiracy had overtaken them. Guilt, or perhaps a wish to make amends, convinced them that they owed Mrs. Swann an interpretation that would reinforce her strengths as a poet. They wanted to offer her help and protection, what she seemed never to have

The final section of the novel takes place at a symposium celebrating Swan’s work, where all four characters gather for the first time. This section takes the form of a film script and plays on the mystery aspect of the novel where all the meaningful items relating to Mary Swann have been stolen – the copies of her work, her pen, the only remaining photos – until Swann’s work literally remains only in the minds of her readers.

She’s the right person at the right time for one thing: a woman, a survivor, self-created.

Swann is a delight of a book, beautifully structured and featuring a host of fantastically realised characters. The book is a satisfying comedy of manners, yet always at the heart is Mary Swann. Carol Shields never lets us forget this unknowable woman whose words have touched so many, but who could have just as easily gone unread and unknown. Perhaps her affection for Mary Swann comes from her own belief that her own work could easily have been overlooked. In an interview she once said,

“I could easily have been …one of those women who erases herself, who somehow slips out of her own life. I only missed it by one generation”

By understanding the possibility of being the one who falls through the cracks, Shields brings real heart to this charming, funny and beautifully written book.

Read On: iBooks

Number Read: 247

Number Remaining: 499

The 746

Cathy746books View All →

I am a 40 something book buying addict trying to reduce the backlog one book at a time!

15 Comments Leave a comment

  1. This sounds excellent, I really like the ideas she’s exploring here and Carol Sheilds is always a safe pair of hands! I’ve really got out of the habit of reading her, but I think this novel will be my way back.


  2. Cathy, what an amazing review. I’ve only read The Stone Diaries (twice, and planning to re-read), but Carol Shields is an author whose catalog I’ve meant to read. I have Unless on my shelf so that will probably be next, but Swann sounds so intriguing I will definitely be picking it up. And congrats on breaking 500! Since I started reading your blog, your TBR has dropped while mine has grown…maybe we’ll meet in the middle! 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

    • I have The Stone Diaries lined up next Priscilla – she is such a wonderful writer isn’t she? I read Unless a long time ago but remember loving it. I’m feeling all proud of myself for getting into the 400s until I remember how long it’s taken me to get here and how far I still have to go!

      Liked by 1 person

  3. I have admired all her work… a brilliant author. I was so glad to hear that a new literary prize honouring Carol Sheilds has just been announced. It will be awarded to female authors from Canada and the US. The top prize will be $150,000.00 and prizes of $12,500.00 to the top remaining finalists.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Val Penny's Book Reviews

By Crooked Cat author, Val Penny

a hot cup of pleasure

There is nothing more satisfying than reading a book while sipping a hot cup of tea.

warm days will never cease

A classic is a book that has never finished saying what it has to say. – Italo Calvino

Maphead's Book Blog

Pillaging the public library so you don't have to.

In Another Era

A historical fiction book blog

Meanderings of a BookWorm

Books. Books. Books

tomcat in the red room

A blog about books

Words And Peace

Book reviews and good books for you to read

Books to Pen

Creative Writing

%d bloggers like this: