300 Arguments by Sarah Manguso for #NovNov

It’s Non-fiction week this week for Novellas in November and I’m kicking off with this short work by Sarah Manguso.

Reading 300 Arguments makes you feel like Manguso has given you all the jigsaw pieces and is asking you to put them together with no idea of what the finished piece should look like. The book is made up of short ‘arguments’ or aphorisms, exploring themes such as love, grief and the act of writing.

Late on in the book, Manguso states

Think of this as a short book composed entirely of what I hoped would be a long book’s quotable passages

300 Arguments feels like you are reading highlighted or bookmarked sentences, or someone’s clever Instagram posts. It has its moments, but for me is not overly successful.

There are concise and expressive statements on love, like a vase, a heart breaks once. After that, it just yields to its flaws’ and the appreciation of the small moment of beauty that need to be remembered.

‘The first beautiful songs you hear tend to stay beautiful because better than beauty, which is everywhere, is the memory of first discovering beauty.’

There are starker moments of honest self-appraisal which seem to fit the description of ‘argument’ in that they ask you to question whether or not you agree. ‘You’ll never know what your mother went through’ is a truism that will mean something different to every reader.

There are passages that feel like condensed short stories, promising much more than they offer and offering just a framework of a feeling that can move from the personal of the author to the personal of the reader.

“There are people I wanted so much before I had them that the entire experience of having them was grief for my old hunger.”

At times though, these snippets can come across as glib or empty. When she states that ‘people congregate according to their relative levels of luck’ my first thought is to question rather than agree. And maybe that’s the point, but a phrase like ‘even inner beauty can fade too’ feels more throwaway than insightful.

The style of the book works well when Manguso is exploring self-doubt, particularly in terms of her work and these passages have a lot more heft than others, reflecting her need to write and to leave evidence about her life.

“I wish someone would tell me what I should be doing instead of this, that he’d be right, and that I’d believe him.”

The extent to which you find 300 Arguments interesting will depend on how you react to its very form. While some of the passages gave me pause for thought, I often felt that I was scrolling through someone’s Twitter feed and could find no hook to hang it all on. The tone of the writing is always serious, and the lack of humour or wit leaves the book on a monotone plane.

Towards the end Manguso states that ‘I like writing that is unsummarizable, a kernel that cannot be condensed, that must be uttered exactly as it is’. I do think she has achieved that in 300 Arguments, but whether or not it creates a satisfying reading experience is an argument all its own.

nonfiction Novellas in November

Cathy746books View All →

I am a 40 something book buying addict trying to reduce the backlog one book at a time!

21 Comments Leave a comment

  1. It sounds like one of those calendars where you have a quote a day that Dutch people often have in their downstairs toilets, along with the birthday calendar, mentioned in this post on my expat blog: https://integratedexpat.wordpress.com/2015/02/18/5-peculiar-things-you-may-find-in-a-dutch-bathroom The quotation or fact f the day type calendars, you read it, tear the page off and throw it away, instantly forgetting it. Or I suppose you might keep the na that speak to you to go into the “I’ll write a blog post about that one day” file. You probably never will write that blog post, either. Great Christmas presents, though.

    Like

  2. It sounds like this is missing some context for all of these revelations and “arguments.” Some of the writing sounds interesting but I think I would be frustrated with it and unsatisfied as you were. What a shame, seems there was a good idea mixed in there somewhere! Great review though, you really picked out some interesting points.

    Like

  3. This sounds interesting to me and yet… not. I think because it sounds like something I’d want to pick up, put down for later, pick up again – instead of reading in one sitting. And that sort of frustrates me in book format. Great review, though!

    Like

  4. Often the reason the quotable passages of a book stick out so much is the context and background that comes before, or what it leads on to. To try and strip out the most quotable parts seems like a mistake to me – without context for understanding they are inherently going to be less meaningful. Shame that this didn’t quite work.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Contemporary Irish Literature

Postgraduate-led research group sharing research and bringing together academics and practitioners to explore contemporary Irish literature.

littlesmackerel

Writing, concerts, theatre and a little bit of travel

italic bookmarks

bookmarks that enhance your reading experience

The Brown Eyed Bookworm

book reviews and all things bookish

BooksPlease

A book lover writes about this, that and the other

From Pyrenees to Pennines

We went to France ..... and then we came back.

The Chocolate Lady's Book Review Blog

For mostly adult, literary, fiction; focusing on historical, contemporary, biographical, and women.

The Opinionated Reader

"There is a stubbornness about me that never can bear to be frightened at the will of others"

%d bloggers like this: