Two memoirs for #DisabilityPrideMonth

July is #DisabilityPrideMonth which, dispiritingly but not unexpectedly, doesn’t get quite the attention in the media it deserves.

To mark the month, I read two very different memoirs, both of which explore the experiences of living with life-changing and life-ending disabilities. Both are written from very different perspectives and in very different styles, but both emphasise the power of the human spirit and the expansive nature of love.

It’s Not Yet Dark by Simon Fitzmaurice

In 2008 Simon Fitzmaurice appeared to have it all. A fledgling filmmaker, he had just had his second short film accepted to Sundance. He was renovating a beautiful house in the country with his wife, the writer Ruth Fitzmaurice, who was pregnant with their second child. While in Utah at the screening of his film, he developed a nagging pain in his foot and following a series of tests was diagnosed with Motor Neurone Disease and given three to four years to live. He was 34.  In 2010, Simon’s lungs collapsed and against the advice of doctors, he was home ventilated and lived for another seven years. During that time, despite the loss of almost all motor function, he embraced innovative technology, which allowed him to complete his feature length film My Name is Emily, have three more children and write this astonishing memoir.

I’ve lost so much. And yet I’m still here.

I feel everything. The slightest feather touch anywhere on my body. And my heart is alive. To meaning. To value. To love. Which is all it’s ever been about.

Written using an eye-gaze computer, It’s Not Yet Dark is a moving and unapologetic account of living with a disease that you know will end your life. Yet, ironically, Fitzmaurice does not allow MND to define him. He writes of his childhood, his teenage years, now he met his wife and his enduring love of film, particularly Wim Wender’s Wings of Desire. He also writes vividly of the toll that MND takes on his body, realising all the ‘last times’ that he has experienced – the last time he danced with Ruth, the last time he walked on his own, the last time he drank a cup of coffee and heartbreakingly, the last time he held his son.

It’s tough to read, but necessarily so, yet Fitzmaurice doesn’t wallow.  He is clear-eyed when describing the consultant who effectively tells him that he would be better off dying than opting for home ventilation or when he talks about the difficulty of being seen no longer as a man, but as a man in a wheelchair. Yet mostly he details the moments of happiness that carry him on and through, mostly centred around his family and his love of art, and he creates a fierce and tender manifesto for living, for the strength of will and for the simple power or hope against all the odds.

When I die, don’t say, Simon loved films, say, Simon had as much love in him as blood. That’s all.

It’s Not Yet Dark was made into a documentary the year before Simon Fitzmaurice’s death and is narrated by Colin Farrell and his wife Ruth has also written a beautiful memoir entitled I Found My Tribe.

I Live A Life Like Yours by Jan Grue , translated by B.L Crook

I Live A Life Like Yours is less urgent than It’s Not Yet Dark, but is no less affecting. When he was 3 years old, Norwegian writer Grue was diagnosed with spinal muscular atrophy, a degenerative disease that compromised his ability to walk, requiring him to use a wheelchair, with the prognosis that his condition would only get worse and drastically shorten his life. In this frank and thoughtful memoir, Grue reflects on disability, identity, and difference, by drawing on philosophy and literature to examine what it means to be different in this world. Blessed with parents who were determined to allow their son to flourish, Grue examines his path to academia, a successful writing career and life as a husband and father.

I would like to think myself away from my body, away from my injured, worn ankles. But there is no me that exists apart from this body, in some unmarked form. That body would have lived an entirely different sort of life.

What hits home the most about this book, is the marginalisation that Grue experiences throughout his life and how society really doesn’t cater for anyone with a physical difference. He notes that two-thirds of most cities are inaccessible to him. An avid traveller, he is often treated with indifference, or outright disdain by transport staff. His attempts to secure accommodation for a year studying in Berkeley have a Kafka-esque quality to them and would be amusing if his experience wasn’t so frustrating. Worse still, he is unable to be present for the birth of his son because the hospital cannot source a protective covering for his wheelchair.

Yet, like Simon Fitzmaurice, this is no pity party. I Live a Life Like Yours is not simply an account of the trials Grue has had to face, nor is it a jaunty redemptive tale of a life lived to the full against the odds. It is a discreet, fiercely intelligent and self-aware appraisal of what it means to be physically disabled and denied a ‘normal’ life.  Through an examination of his childhood medical records and his the obstacles he has since overcome, Grue fashions a thoughtful mediation on what makes us human, and like Fitzmaurice, what that is centred upon is love, hope and an indomitable will.

The 746

Cathy746books View All →

I am a 40 something book buying addict trying to reduce the backlog one book at a time!

21 Comments Leave a comment

  1. I reviewed the Grue for Shelf Awareness. I’ve read Ruth Fitzmaurice’s memoir but not her husband’s. Have you read The Diving Bell and the Butterfly? I think that was also written by eye gaze (but with a human assistant).

    Liked by 1 person

  2. It’s amazing to see what some are able to accomplish despite adversity. I also read the Diving Bell and thought it was excellent. I’ve also read Ady Barkan’s book Eyes to the Wind which was so memorable. Thanks for sharing.


  3. Such an important subject but as you say, not one that receives a great deal of coverage. Diving Bell was a bestseller when I was a bookseller and I’m sure must have raised awareness of MND considerably at the time.


  4. These both sound excellent. I’m reading a chronic illness memoir at the moment, Suleika Jaouad’s Between Two Kingdoms, which is very good on both the experience of leukaemia and the difficulties of living in remission.

    I thought the author of Diving Bell had a stroke rather than MND? But he did use the same eye tech.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Yes, I think you are right, the Diving Bell was about a stroke. The Fitzmaurice is very moving, obviously because he knew he didn’t have long to go and it is good to read alongside Ruth Fitzmaurice’s memoir too.

      Liked by 1 person

  5. Jan Grue’s memoir was on the Barbellion Prize submission list (and we longlisted it, too) – it really is good. My favourite is still Josie George’s stunning A Still Life, but this year I’ve been bowled over by Chloe Cooper Jones’s Easy Beauty, about her life with sacral agenesis and what it’s like to so visibly flout conventional notions of “the beautiful body”. Really great and highly recommended.

    Liked by 1 person

  6. These books sound very interesting reads. While on holidays I was aware of just a few people here and there on wheelchairs in different places and I thought it may have been extremely difficult for them to navigate many life situations and also how embarrassing little I knew about handicapped people. There was a happy boy in a stroller pushed by grandma who was older but couldn’t walk without braces but who could enjoy the pool with them, but temporarily couldn’t because he got blisters in his feet due to the heat. They weren’t painful without the metal braces. The boy so far was very talkative and happy despite his handicap. But I don’t have a clue how simple daily things are or will be for him.

    Thanks for these reviews.

    Liked by 1 person

  7. I read and reviewed the Jan Grue one around Christmastime and found his achievements quite inspiring – and quite eye-opening on a child’s perspective of growing up with a disability (I keep an eye on the Barbellion list as I’m always interesting in writing on disability because of my younger daughter’s CP).

    Liked by 1 person

  8. I’m glad these books exist but I’m not resilent enough to read them myself! I meant to read the book Golem Girl in July but failed as I ran out of reading time through too much going out (shockingly) but will read it for All Virago/All August if I can. Still a tough read but not with the approaching death bit.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Fran McBookface

Blethering all things books

Tasmanian Bibliophile @Large

'Inside a book is a different world...'


A friendly space for all horror, mystery & speculative fiction lovers

Plucked from the Stacks

book reviews and chatter

The Intrepid Arkansawyer

The Intrepid Angeleno is presently in Arkansas.

Books and Me!

All things Bookish and more!

Lizzie Ross

Reading, writing, dreaming

Book of Secrets

A Book Review Blog

%d bloggers like this: